This Watergate Salad has served me well over the years. It’s on every holiday menu I create and my family expects it for Christmas, Thanksgiving, and all the rest. I don’t mind that at all! I love this recipe because it’s super easy to make. This creamy dessert can also be made ahead so it’s easy to add to any busy holiday meal. If you like dessert salads like I do, you have to try my Creamy Grape Salad, Orange Fluff Salad, and my Ambrosia Salad Recipes. For a cookie version of this classic salad, I have a Watergate Cookie Recipe that you’re going to love!
What is a Watergate Salad?
Unlike traditional salads full of vegetables and leafy greens, Watergate salad really isn’t a salad at all, but a dessert made with instant pudding, whipped cream, and delicious add-ins like crushed pineapple and nuts. If you’re from the Midwest you are probably fully experienced with dessert salads, as this area of the country is now well-known for its expertise in creating them. All types of sweet, fluffy dessert salads can be found at potlucks and holiday tables. This type of dessert salad was made popular around the time that instant gelatin was first made available to the public, around 1930, and the Watergate salad came after Pistachio pudding was created, in 1975.
Why You’ll Love This Recipe
Watergate Salad Ingredients
Pistachio Pudding: You’ll need one box of pistachio flavored instant pudding mix. JELL-O is the most common brand, but a store brand will work too. I prefer the regular variety, but there is a sugar free/fat free version if that fits your dietary needs better. Be sure to pick up instant pudding mix, rather than the cook and serve type. Crushed Pineapple: There are many types of canned pineapple, so make sure you grab the right one! For this recipe you want unsweetened crushed pineapple in juice, not syrup. Syrupy crushed pineapple is too heavy for this recipe. Miniature Marshmallows: these add bulk and chewiness to the fluffy salad. In a pinch you could chop up full sized marshmallows, but minis work perfectly. Chopped Nuts: You can use either pistachios or pecans. I prefer pecans so I used them here, but either is acceptable. Whipped Topping: Again, I prefer the regular version, but low fat options are available too. Thaw your whipped topping before mixing. Maraschino Cherries: These are our garnish. The bright red is so striking against the green of the salad, and perfect for Christmas.
Complete list of ingredients and amounts can be found in the recipe card below.
How to Make Watergate Salad
Recipe Success Tips
Don’t overthink it! This recipe really is as simple as it sounds. Mix everything together per the instructions and you’ll have the perfect Watergate salad. Be Gentle. The whipped topping shouldn’t be stirred into the pudding mixture, but rather folded in. Use a rubber spatula to slowly cut down to the bottom of the bowl and then lift up and fold over. It’s ok if there are some streaks of white.
Watergate Salad Variations
Since this is a fairly old, traditional recipe, there have been hundreds of variations created over the years. What I’m sharing with you here is the original recipe, as far as I understand. I’d love to hear in the comments how you make yours special! Here are a few things you could try:
Use Mandarin Oranges – Substitute mandarin oranges for all or some of the crushed pineapple for a sweeter, juicier salad. Add Coconut – I’ve seen many recipes where sweetened, flaked coconut is added for both texture and flavor. Try adding ¼ to ½ cup to the mix. Use different Nuts – try almonds or walnuts, or leave them out altogether if you prefer. Add more Cherries – You can chop up maraschino cherries and add them right into the mix instead of using them for garnish only.
Why do they call it Watergate Salad?
This salad became popular in Washington, D.C., during the time that President Richard Nixon resigned from office due to the Watergate scandal. It seems that the name just came because of the timing. Nobody can really pinpoint who started calling it that, but the name stuck. And while you no longer can find Watergate salad on lunch menus in D.C., the recipe lives on through home cooks across the country.
How many cups are in a cool whip container?
An 8-oz. tub of Cool Whip or other whipped topping is 3 cups. If you’re using a larger-sized Cool Whip container, you may need to measure out the correct amount.
What type of salad is Watergate Salad?
Watergate salad is a dessert salad. Much different than a traditional salad, dessert salads are more of a pudding than a salad and more of a dessert than a side dish. Sometimes this dessert is called pistachio delight or green delight. That term seems to make more sense than the word salad, but alas, it is what it is! Whatever you want to call it, it’s still delicious.
Can I make this salad with regular pistachio pudding mix?
The recipe calls for the powder from a box of instant pistachio pudding mix. Instant pudding works in dessert salads because it will set up quickly without adding any heat. Cook-and-serve pudding won’t thicken up properly in this recipe. Enjoy making this American classic Watergate Salad! Make sure to pin this recipe so that more people can enjoy it too. © Little Sunny Kitchen
